Friday, September 21, 2012

The Melting Pot of Justice


The on goings of police officers and their arguably unjust actions when associating stereotypes has been a greatly debated topic in class this last week. When the question, whether or not it was just to impose prejudice based on past experience was first posed, I automatically believed any prejudice in any manner was a great injustice. However, as the class divulged into what were seemingly exceptions. I became torn.
As one abiding by Kant’s ethical theory, it is a straightforward choice between right and wrong, when considering formulation of a biased action. The Universal Law of Justice to which Kant adheres states that one should “act externally in such a way that the free use of your will is compatible with the freedom of everyone according to universal law.” In this sense, it appears that one may develop a prejudice opinion but is not committing an injustice until he or she wills said prejudice. In that case, the freedom of the one in which the discrimination is directed is violated.
Contrastingly, after reading the excerpt from John Stuart Mills, “On the Connexion between Justice and Utility,” the idea that “the feeling of justice might be a peculiar instinct,” rang a certain truth. In proving his point, Mills argued the fact that as human beings we distinctly believe harm or retribution should come to those who do harm to, not only ourselves, but to others as well. Security, therefore, is the most protected human rights. With that being said, it would make sense to create a negative attitude towards those similar to a person who poses harm to humankind and their rights in general.
It seems to me that there are always shades of grey when a group of people from varying backgrounds come together and attempt to place a distinct definition on a term as encompassing as justice. When I ponder the true meaning of justice, I find that a mixture of the “great thinkers” ideas should be considered. In comparison to the nickname given to America, the melting pot, the closest to perfection one can become is a combination of many critical ideas. On the other hand, taking the concepts and theories from philosophers out of context could be detrimental to their true meaning.
As students of so many varying opinions are we inclined to choose a single point of view to adhere by? Or is it that we should take each argument as equally important and applicable and use them all in the society we have built today?

Trolley vs. Transplant



It seemed fairly inevitable and obvious that everyone would blog about the Trolley Problem after we discussed it in class today. Although Wikipedia is not an entirely credible source, it gives many different variations of the Trolley Problem. Here is the link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem. One alternative situation that did not use a trolley stated the following: “A brilliant transplant surgeon has five patients, each in need of a different organ, each of whom will die without that organ. Unfortunately, there are no organs available to perform any of these five transplant operations. A healthy young traveler, just passing through the city the doctor works in, comes in for a routine checkup. In the course of doing the checkup, the doctor discovers that his organs are compatible with all five of his dying patients. Suppose further that if the young man were to disappear, no one would suspect the doctor.” How different do you think that this situation is from the ones that we discussed in class? Essentially you would be doing the same thing – taking away one person’s life so you can save the lives of many. Personally, somehow, this situation seems to be more morally conflicting than the trolley situation. It seems worse to sacrifice an innocent man who was just going to the doctor for a simple check-up, than someone who was (unintelligently) loitering on the trolley tracks. 

Furthermore, in the trolley situation you are sure that you would save the ten people that are stuck standing on the one side of the tracks. In the surgeon situation, you are not entirely sure that the five patients will survive even if they receive the right organs. Numerous possibilities are present that could cause the death of any number of the five – infection, miscalculations,  unexpected response to the organ, a surgical error, the list can go on and on. So when the surgeon chooses to sacrifice the innocent man to donate his organs to the needy five patients, he cannot truly guarantee that his choice will save all or any of his patients. The doctor could accidently manage to kill all six of them.

What do some of you guys think? Do you think that both situations are equal? Would killing the one man on the tracks be the same as killing the one man for his organs? Or does one seem to be a worse offense than the other?

Utilitarianism and Evolution


When talking about the “trolley problem” in class, most people took a utilitarian stance.  It seemed instinctive and obvious that we should sacrifice the life of one person to save the lives of ten others.  Why does this come so naturally to us, though? One can make a solid argument that taking no action is more blameless than actively killing a man.  By choosing to enter the situation, you’ve taken on a responsibility that may not be yours to take on.  

I think the answer lies in the evolution of our species.  Throughout the early stages of our development, it was advantageous to look out for the good of the whole.  The early humans who were able to predict the outcomes that would follow their actions gained an advantage both in individual and group survival.  Take yourself back to such a situation: if there are only a few hundred or thousand members of your species, the 10:1 utilitarian calculus seems much more urgent.  Over the course of our history, we’ve been put through ordeals in which it was advantageous to look out for the good of our group/tribe/species.  The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy has a good page on Evolutionary Ethics, if you’re interested: http://www.iep.utm.edu/evol-eth/ .


While that might explain why we naturally gravitate toward utilitarian behavior today, it doesn’t address whether it makes sense to continue with utilitarianism as a primary driving force behind our actions.  What do you think?  I believe utilitarianism definitely has merits, and it’s highly integral to the way most of the world’s political systems function.  In fact, I think every philosopher we’ve studied so far agrees with utilitarian logic to a degree.  Plato’s argument for why injustice isn’t profitable lies with the disruption of cooperation and a common sense of purpose; justice is achieved when everyone does what is best for the whole.  Aristotle believes that justice can only arise from the interactions between people and that we should aim for a virtuous mean in all things; rational, equitable interactions produce an effect that benefits society as a whole.  I think Kant would not agree that “killing a person is ok” could be exerted as a universal law, but I believe he might encounter a “conflict of obligations” that would guide him to save the ten people.  What do you think?

That being said, I think there are definitely merits to the idea that we can’t always accurately predict the consequences of our actions. If we consider a more realistic version of our versions of the trolley problem, we run into a whole host of variables.  How do you know that the ten people on an active track couldn’t get out of the way?  The single person on a track that doesn’t normally get traffic at that time certainly won’t be expecting it. How do you know those people aren’t suicidal and won’t simply kill themselves anyway (why else are they loitering around on a trolley track?)?  There are a lot of variables at play when we examine real life situations that utilitarian logic cannot take into account.  I realize that our discussion intentionally made many variables into constants, but we don't necessarily have that luxury when applying it in everyday life.

Let's Talk About Batman (and Kant) (and Mill)


We discussed the Trolley Problem today in class, considering several variables that would complicate anyone's utilitarian decision.  One large difficulty we saw with Mill's utilitarianism is that, unlike Kant's theory, there is not a rule that can make deciding whether any action in a given situation is moral or not a clear decision.  Under Kant, I would argue that the Trolley Problem is not a situation that deals with justice.  In the first place, no action one may take in that circumstance aligns with Kant's Universal Law of Justice--that the free use of your will is compatible with the freedom of everyone.  Whether you pull the lever or not, your actions are incompatible with the freedom of whoever dies as a result.  Do you agree with this?  Or would this simply be a situation in which one's only options are unjust actions?  

I think we can all agree that it is, whether justice is involved or not, a morality problem.  Considering this, I wonder what you think Kant would do if faced with the Trolley Problem?  I think that Kant would not pull the lever (or push the fat man) in order to save the lives of 10 other people.  Because Kant is not concerned with the ends of any action (just the actions themselves), it would be immoral to force the death of anyone.  By not acting, it is true that 10 people will die, but because Kant was not responsible for the action that caused their deaths, he is acting morally (or at least not immorally).  Who really knows what Kant would do, but in this scenario I'm only concerned with what Kant would view as the morally right action.  What do you think?

So, Batman!  In The Dark Knight, the Joker kidnaps Harvey Dent, the District Attorney and white knight of Gotham, and Rachel, Batman's crush and Harvey Dent's girlfriend.  He puts them in two different warehouses full of explosives set to explode on a timer.  The idea is that Batman is told where they both are, but because the warehouses are far apart and he cannot get to them both before they explode, he must choose who he is going to save.  This seems to me to be a good example of a problem we faced with utilitarianism--weighing the value of a human life to yourself, versus the value of a human life to the world.  I'm not sure this scene is a perfect example, though, as the Joker lies to Batman about which hostage is in which warehouse.  Batman intends to save Rachel, but he walks in to find Harvey Dent instead.  It seems he intended to choose his love interest over the believed savior of Gotham.

Have a look:

My final consideration is, what do you think Kant would do in this scenario?  Would it matter who is saved, so long as you attempt to save one of them?

Action vs. Reasoning


Action vs. Reasoning
Caution: The following blog is full of possibly the following: erroneous comments, irrational sentiment, ignorance, and contrite reasoning. It may also resemble: knowledge, thought provoking matter and ideas that make you question your own conclusions.
I do not believe that this is my week to post a blog; however, I feel that I am moved to do such. My goal is always to further complicate and as the southern proverb says, “Muddy the waters”, and I do this so that you (reader) can taste what the battlefield of my mind is like. I missed my opportunity last week to post, therefore, even though I won’t be graded on this post, I will still try my best to give a good situation to make you use your noggin!
                Using the multiple situations today presented in class as your basis for reasoning, my goal is to set up a situation in such a way that makes you come to a conclusion hopefully somewhat similar to my own, or to negate my reasoning. My conclusion that I drew today from class is this: In having to bring yourself too mentally and physical do more to kill, does that change your ability to kill?
                In the situation of the trolley, as presented, it is coming and you can pull a lever saving the ten people and killing the one; or, do not pull the lever and the one lives and the ten die. My reaction (and some of yours) was that I would pull the lever. When the fat man on the bridge idea was presented (push the fat man over, killing one, saves the ten because his massive body stops the train) I had to mull it over for a minute. My reasoning for doing so was because I felt as if I was actually killing (pushing him to his fate) through my actions. This, in comparison to pulling a lever and not actually pushing a person, in my mind, made the lever not as wrong as actually pushing. Yes, your killing in either circumstance, however, you are putting more effort in terms of mental decision making, in my opinion.
                Now if any of that makes sense, on to the “Taylor situation of impending doom”, as I have named it. Imagine waking up in a room that is completely pitch black. You then hear over a loud speaker, “Let’s play a game”. The “game” is now described to you in a very terrifying manner, and the content of the message is as follows:
You have a decision to make.
You can strangle the person to your left who is bound against their will and save ten who are in a gas chamber.
You can decide not to strangle the one to your left, but the ten in the gas chamber will be suffocated by poisonous gas.
If you decide to kill yourself, everyone dies.
If you decide to not do anything, everyone dies.
Now, you seem to be in a situation, one which has impending doom for some if not all. What do you do? Can you bring yourself to strangle/ brutally murder another person?
This leads me back to my conclusion as stated above: In having to bring yourself too mentally and physical do more to kill, does that change your ability to kill?
What do you think? Does this make your brain hurt, as it did mine?
P.s. (I was thinking of the movie Saw as I came up with my situation).

Decisions, Decisions

We spent a lot of time in class today talking about the trolley problem and then later the classrooms with the buttons example. It was particularly interesting to me because this was not the first philosophy class I have had where this problem is proposed. In every class that it has been brought up in, we always spend a great deal of time on it and continuously come back to it. However, the most interesting thing I have noticed in my classes is that when the problem is first brought up, people hesitate to give a firm answer before asking questions about the circumstances proposed and/or altering the scenario to make it either one that seems easier to make a decision from or further complicate it. This makes sense because at the end of the day, as much as we contemplate what we would do or what we should do we don’t actually know. It seems easier for us to take a stand when we know more about a situation and can in a way feel like we are justifying our decision based on the facts we obtain. Whether the problem is brought up in an ethics class or social and political philosophy class, it is difficult to predict what our actions would be. We can theorize what Mill’s utilitarian approach would dictate or what Kant’s deontological philosophy would necessitate but we can’t go much farther then that. So do examples like the trolley problem show that in the real world we can’t adopt one philosophy over another? Is it more realistic to acknowledge that we take different parts from various philosophies and meld them together to create something that we can try to follow and makes us feel good? One of the reasons I enjoy discussing these examples is because it exposes the gap between what we can say is the logical thing to do and what we would actually do. What happens when logic seems to fail us and we don't think we could do what logic entails? The majority would probably agree that when we are in real life situations where a decision has to be made, logic is not the only factor we consider. Is it realistic or productive to focus on the logical reasons only? Should we be trying to work towards making logical solutions that aren’t influenced by other factors? Is that even possible?

Thursday, September 20, 2012

To abandon ship, or not to abandon ship...?

When thinking about Kant's cases of "equivocal justice," I always come back to the right of necessity.  I keep thinking of our boat scenario except instead of two people it is a captain with his crew and guests who are all on board. Now, we have all heard and read and seen that a captain is supposed to go down with his ship. There are indeed some statutes, that come with prosecutions and punishments, that back up this ever so fictional idea that the captain should stay with his ship, or at least be the last one to exit. In the Merchant Marines Officers' Handbook for instance one of the first duties of the "master"/captain is to be "1. The last man to leave the vessel" (Allen, 1).  Today we see abandoning one's ship and its passengers as something of an atrocious and selfish act, and we charge people with it to much of the full extent that is possible. Although it seems terrible, it is not that out of line with the right of necessity; although given no legal right to leave and let the rest of ones passengers fend for themselves or drown, there is also this necessity to save yourself. According to Kant, it becomes more business of the conscious rather than for the court.

I wonder what Kant would think about our more or less charging and punishing to the max those captains who do abandon their ships...in some cases wouldn't we have done the same? Even if we do try to make it a  matter of the court should they not show some sort of indulgence (leniency) as according to Kant, even though it doesn't really seem to be "fair" to us or those he/she left?



Allen, Craig H. "The Captain's Duty on a Sinking Ship." WashingtonLaw.edu, n.d. Web. <http://www.law.washington.edu/Directory/docs/Allen/Publications/Article_1994_CaptainsDutySinkingShipTake2.pdf>.

A Universal Right to Love?

Today in class Dr. J gave an example of right to necessity that involved issues of love and marriage. To summarize, she suggested that if in the 1940's she, a white woman, had fallen madly in love with a black man, that she had no right to marry him, but she possessed a necessity to do so. In response to this, I asked if Kant would consider this to be rational, because it was a matter of intense emotions;
Dr. Johnson reminded me that what is necessary for an act or law to be considered rational is that it adheres to the principles of the categorical imperative, specifically in this case the first tenet-- "One must act only in such a way that one could will the maxim of one's actions as a universal law."

Perhaps I sound like a broken record at this point, but here again I will turn to the subject of gay rights. Dr. Johnson's example need not have been one dated to more than seventy years ago when there are still limitations on a person's ability to marry whom they chose-- namely, that gay marriage is still not recognized as legal in most states. In this instance, if I as a woman fell madly in love with another woman to the point of necessity, the second instance of equivocal justice, then I would marry her. The issue here is that cases of equivocal justice are in fact not instances when justice is able to be applied-- they are in fact exceptions to Kant's previously defined application of justice. Furthermore, the acknowledgment that this is an example of right to necessity equivocal justice allows the concession that I, as a women in love with another women, do not have the right to marry her, even though I do so to preserve my emotional self. This is, in a sense, what gay couples have done for the past several decades-- my own parents among them. They have acknowledged that the government does not allow them the right to marry, but in order to honor their own nature they have built relationships that are equivalent to marriages in all but the legal sense to fulfill their necessity.

Still, all of this is to treat the issue of homosexual relationships, or more broadly in fact all types of romantic or committed relationship, as a matter of exception to justice. I believe that this is not that case, nor do I believe that Kant would consider it to be so. That each rational agent should be able to freely choose whom they want to build a relationship with is in accordance with the categorical imperative-- this law can be applied universally, without infringing on the free will of another person and without treating another person as merely a means to an end. By this understanding, all relationships between free and rational agents (meaning excluding bestiality from the realm of possibility) ought to be considered just and moral.

In American politics, this would be generally accepted on the subject of arranged marriages (that this defies this law) and interracial marriages (that these unions are acceptable), but not so much when it comes to polygamy or, to my point, gay marriage. So according to the conservative voices (primarily Christian in the United States), the right to choose whom one wishes to marry is not universally applicable.

To this point, then, I say that Kant would still have grounds to disagree. Even if you feel that the law of the right to marry at your own will cannot be applied universally (therefore, you believe that homosexual relationships are irrational), the fact still stands that the ultimate element for Kant is each person's own free will. For any individual to deny his or her own free will is to deny their rationality. Therefore, so that each person might be in accordance with his or her own free will, equal rights to chose whom one builds a lifelong commitment with is a necessity.




Monday, September 17, 2012

Necessity Has No Law: Objectivity and Subjectivity of Justice

Kant's Right of Necessity, the second case that is exempt from jurisprudence proper, is interesting to me. It sidesteps jurisprudence and brings common sense and natural instincts to the forefront in one go. Self-defense laws seem to be no-brainers, yet there is a rational and irrational side to them.

Kant talks about self-defense, giving the example of two men stranded, floating on a wooden plank. He explains how one man pushes the other off the plank (to drown) in order to save himself and float to safety. Survival instincts take over, and all laws are forgotten, as Kant notes, "no punishment threatened by the law could be greater than losing his life," and so the first man shoves of the other without thinking of legal repercussions, assuming he lives through the situation. The animal instincts of the first man drowns out (pun intended) his rational, moral inclinations. Instead of working together to find a way out of the situation, both men are thinking irrationally since they're in a life/death situation. So, the stronger takes the advantage (Plato, anyone?).

Kant then says, even if there were laws dictating such situations, it wouldn't produce the intended effect because "the threat of an evil that is still uncertain (being condemned to death by a judge) cannot outweigh the fear of an evil that is certain (being drowned)." But there are still moral repercussions to a situation. Unless you're a wacked-out sociopath, no one kills another person and just moves on, right? So even if there are no legal effects on the survivor, once his rationality comes back to him, won't he be in pain? Kant writes, "what he must judge for himself as unjust in itself will be treated with indulgence by the court."

Not only will the survivor not be punished in court, but he cannot be held responsible for his actions. For instance, he won't be put to death when he reaches home because he (essentially) killed a man in order to survive. Nowadays, this is true, too. We have laws such as the Castle Doctrine and the Stand-Your-Ground laws to counteract potential lawsuits on defenders.

In sum, I guess what's interesting to me is the objectivity of the idea of justice, yet the subjectivity of its implementation. We are given the extreme case of self-defense at its worst, the case is obviously subjective: one man does an injustice to another, the latter retaliates to offset the imbalance (Aristotle Book V, anyone?). Yet with a non-lifethreatening situation such as shoplifting, the laws are essentially universal (domestically). Is it because of the extremeness of the situation, those in which we assume instincts take over and reason flies out the window, that make otherwise punishable actions permissible? Even shoplifting can be a thinker if put into the same context: someone stealing food for her/his starving family. Objectively, the person stole food: illegal, wrong. period. Subjectively, to feed a starving family: weeellll....? If anything, it would be "understandable."

I dunno, just my thoughts on one section of the Kant reading.

Friday, September 14, 2012

Why To Think Freely

     Kant's entire philosophy is based on people being rational and free and what reason people have for thinking freely.  I would like to place emphasis on the later part as to why people should be able to think freely.  I think that this is extremely important to be able to think freely but in some cultures people are either not allowed to or are not given the education they need to fully comprehend important things at all.  There is a plethora of reasons for us to think freely.  As Aristotle said calculative pleasure is the highest form and if people dont have the opportunity to think freely then they may not get the chance to experience that joy.
     I think that people could have several different reasons for thinking freely, such as to make yourself appear more intelligent to other, to help improve the lives of others and many more.  With all these good options we generally take that for granted.  In many countries across the globe there is governments that force their youth to study only what they want them to and think and believe in the things that are suitable for the state.
     I think that all of us that have gotten into rhodes have the ability to think and do it quite well.  So if we have been given this great opportunity to think then why not do it to the fullest and expand our thinking skills.  Kant talks about Dentology (our certain duties) and I think he would tell us if we have been given the ability to think like most of us can then it is our duty to think and not merely just go through the motions.  Of coarse there are always influences on our ability to think freely like our peers and culture but for the God did give us free will so we should use it.  People thinking freely is what got us to where we are now if we all had the same mindset that someone else wanted you to have then we would not break through any knew territory.  Kant's philosophy is very applicable to all of us especially in a philosophy class because it shows us that regardless of what we are thinking we should think and think for ourselves.