Friday, September 14, 2012

Can Lying be Justified/Moral?



In today’s class we discussed Kant and his belief that there are certain ‘laws’ that we all must follow in order to be considered moral human beings. His belief is that the ‘categorical imperative,’ or what we must always do, consists of three main principles: first, act only in such a way that you could will the maxim of your actions as universal law. Second, act only in such a way that you treat humanity (within yourself or others), never simply as a means, but always as an end-in-itself. Finally, act in accordance with the maxims of a member giving universal laws for a merely possible kingdom of ends. One can use these principles as a way to answer the question “what ought I to do?” (Richards)

Kant believes that this categorical imperative is “the fundamental, universal and indisputable moral truth of the universe, and as such it is the touchstone for judging whether our actions are good, or not.” (Richards) An example that we discussed in class was showing up to class on time. Since all of the students came to [or tried to] come to class on time, they unconsciously or consciously are saying that this action is a universal law or even that it can qualify as a universal law. Since it follows the first principle, it can be considered a good action. On the other hand, lying is generally considered an action that is “bad” (Richards) or immoral. No one believes that lying should be a universal law; if they did then the whole world would collapse.

            There are some problems that arise when we talk about Kantian philosophy, for example, is it moral to tell a lie if telling the truth is going to hurt someone? The classic example of this would be Nazis searching for Anne Frank and her family. If a Nazi soldier came to their house and asked if there were any Jews then wouldn’t it be morally right for the owner of the house to lie? If they didn’t lie then there would be a chance that Anne Frank and her family dies. Would it be moral to lie in that case? Many people would say that it is perfectly fine to lie in that instance. Kant would definitely disagree. He would say that any type of lying is morally wrong and that lying goes against the first principle of the categorical imperative. Why does he believe that? It’s because we live in a world that operates on the notion that everyone tells the truth; but if everyone lies when they wanted to then we would end up in a situation where we wouldn’t be able to trust anyone. Society is built upon the notion that everyone tells the truth; when you are at a supermarket and you are looking for watermelon to buy, you expect to buy a watermelon that hasn’t been de-juiced with a syringe; you expect to get a full juicy watermelon. But if we did live in a world where it was okay to lie then no one would believe a liar anyway, so it is irrational to lie. “If we want to tell lies, then other people should be allowed to tell lies, but then if everyone else is telling lies… you get the picture!” (Richards) Kant believes that since we live in a world where communal interactions are imperative, we can’t “live as we please without due regard and respect for others.” (Richards) We must act as we want others to act. 

Richards, Stephen. "That Religious Studies Website." The Categorical Imperative (Immanuel Kant). N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Sept. 2012. <http://www.thatreligiousstudieswebsite.com/Ethics/Moral_Theory/Deontology/categorical_imperative_kant.php>.

Republican or Democrat or Neither?

     An interesting question I usually ask myself in class when discussing the different philosophies of Plato, Aristotle, and Kant is whether or not their theories would be the same if they lived in today's political world?  Who would be a democrat?  Who would be a republican?  Or would they even associate themselves with political parties?
     From my understanding of the philosophy of Plato, I would most likely put him in the republican category.  Plato's philosophy has a powerful group of guardians governing the rest of the members of society.  Plato theory of a society is set up much like the economic plan of the republican party.  This philosophy has a strong, extremely weathly upperclass aiding in the job distribution for those with lower incomes.  Plato would argue that the ergon of these wealthy businessmen is to ensure the fulfillment of the ergons of the workers.  These strong few must govern the rest of society to ensure it remains in order.
      Aristotle is a little harder to place into a party. Aristotle's theories are heavily based on the idea of meritocracy.  He stresses balance more that Plato does, but believes that a person should only receive what he earns.  But he also stresses equity as something much different than equality.  There are times when equality is not the best policy and equity, the just distribution according to the greatest need, is the better policy in certain situations.  These ideas would subject him into falling into more of an in-between position in politics according to one's definition of a person's need and merit.
     Now Kant, as of what we have discussed so far in class, I would label as a democrat.  I believe Kant's Categorical Imperatives would translate into a a need for a strong middle class.  The first part of his Categorical Imperatives states that one must act in only such a way that you could will the maxim of your actions as a universal law.  This idea reflects the statement Bill Clinton said in his Democratic National Convention speech; the democratic society is one in which "we're all together" instead of the republican idea of "you're on your own".
     Now I am curious to see if any of you agree, disagree, or just think I'm crazy for connecting each of these philosophers with a political party.  I would say there are arguments on either side for each of these philosophers, especially since we are unable to ask them ourselves which party they would affiliate with in today's world.  But I do believe it is an interesting question to ask about each philosopher we study.

Free will vs. Tradition


            One thing that I find particularly interesting about Kant’s philosophy is his emphasis on freedom and its connection to someone performing a just act. According to Kant, if one does something that one would consider just because it is the law or because something like the bible encourages people to do something, Kant would consider this coercion.  A person who does something for any reason besides the fact that they themselves want to do it is coerced.
            Laws and religious teachings are so engraved in our society that it is hard to imagine our society without them. People who don’t follow the law or the bible are usually considered to be ‘bad’ people. Though there have been unjust laws and everything the bible teaches isn’t just. Most laws and things in the bible apply to Kant’s first Categorical Imperative to “act only in such a way that you could will the maxim of your action as a universal law”. There are universal laws and most of the universal laws come from religious source, which is in large part, the purpose of these religious doctrines; to get ensure that any rational citizen would agree that this law is just. However, according to Kant anyone who listens to these is not acting according on their own, they are influenced by another source. Since both laws and religious teachings are so engraved in our society, do you agree with Kant? What would happen if we stopped putting such emphasis on religious teachings or laws? 

The Categorical Imperative and Lying to Murderers

In class earlier today, we discussed the categorical imperative, the supreme ethical principle of Immanuel Kant.  This categorical imperative has three parts:

  1. act only in such a way that you could will the maxim of your actions as a universal law
  2. act only in such a way that you always treat humanity (whether in your own person or another person) never as a means but as an end itself
  3. act in accordance with the maxims of a member giving universal laws for a merely possible kingdom of ends
These three sub-principles make up the categorical imperative.  For Kant, every human being is considered a rational and free actor.  Further, he developed his supreme ethical principle while considering what reason demands for a rational thinker, or for a human.

For most scenarios, Kant's categorical imperative holds up.  For instance, a rational thinker would not impose the universal law of 'stealing is good' on society, therefore, that rational thinker would not steal.  Stealing is thus morally reprehensible.  What about killing?  The rational thinker does not wish to live in a society where murder is morally upright.  Therefore, killing is morally reprehensible.
These types of moral statements seem very appealing.  But, as we saw in class, the application of Kant's categorical imperative does not always produce desirable results.

The Anne Frank scenario we discussed is a clear example of this.  To rehash: you live in Nazi-occupied Europe.  Some Jews are hiding in your attic.  The S.S. have just come to your door and asked if there are any Jews with you.

Following Kant's categorical imperative, you cannot lie.  To do so would infringe on the first sub-principle.  So you must tell the Nazi that there are Jews in your attic.  For Kant, when one tells the truth, one is no longer responsible for the consequences (whereas if one lies, one is fully responsible for the consequences).

Philosopher Benjamin Constant first pointed out this flaw in Kant's categorical imperative.  If a murderer comes to your house, he asked, and demands to know if your friend is home, and you know that the murderer intends to murder your friend, do you tell the murderer the truth?  Kant replied to this objection in On a Supposed Right to Lie because of Philanthropic Concerns.

From that essay: "...if by telling a lie you have in fact hindered someone who was even now planning a murder, then you are legally responsible for all the consequences that might result therefrom. But if you have adhered strictly to the truth, then public justice cannot lay a hand on you, whatever the unforeseen consequence might be. It is indeed possible that after you have honestly answered Yes to the murderer's question as to whether the intended victim is in the house, the latter went out unobserved and thus eluded the murderer, so that the deed would not have come about. However, if you told a lie and said that the intended victim was not in the house, and he has actually (though unbeknownst to you) gone out, with the result that by so doing he has been met by the murderer and thus the deed has been perpetrated, then in this case you may be justly accused as having caused his death. For if you had told the truth as best you knew it, then the murderer might perhaps have been caught by neighbors who came running while he was searching the house for his intended victim, and thus the deed might have been prevented. Therefore, whoever tells a lie, regardless of how good his intentions may be, must answer for the consequences resulting therefrom even before a civil tribunal and must pay the penalty for them, regardless of how unforeseen those consequences may be. This is because truthfulness is a duty that must be regarded as the basis of all duties founded on contract, and the laws of such duties would be rendered uncertain and useless if even the slightest exception to them were admitted."

For Kant, then, to lie in such a situation is to assume responsibility for all the multitude of consequences that would result from such a lie. How many of the murderer's subsequent actions would then be the result of your lie?  Would the guilt of those actions rest equally on your hands, as well as the murderer's?  This brings to mind Aristotle's view on justice, wherein an agent is responsible for injustice if it is done with knowledge of the actions and the outcome resulting.  Would Kant disagree with Aristotle's views on injustice, then?

Much of Kant's argument against lying to the murderer is based in avoiding legal and moral responsibility for the murderer's actions.  I don't find much moral solace in telling the truth if it leads to my friend's death, however.  Does circumstantial judgement supersede ethical absolutes?

Source: http://philosophyfaculty.ucsd.edu/faculty/rarneson/Courses/KANTsupposedRightToLie.pdf

Irrational rationality?


We’ve heard in class many times that “Rational people thinking rationally” will agree that something is either true or false, logical or illogical, but is that necessarily the case? One of the most fascinating things about human beings in general is that we can all examine the same thing, but all come away with different but equally valid impressions of what we examined. An easy example of this is the United States Constitution. While the document itself is the same, there are multitudes of different interpretations of it, all by rational people thinking rationally. Is one more right or correct, one that is a definite, completely factual interpretation?

 In the case of Kantian philosophy, it was argued today that lying in the Anne Frank situation would still be immoral because it violated the first principle: that it would not be a good maxim for everyone to follow as a rule. Though the action might be justified, it would still create the problem of an unjust general rule, however is this really the case? A rational person thinking rationally could conclude that this condones lying to save someone’s life, which means lying is acceptable at times when lives are at stake. If lying was acceptable at those times, a rational person thinking rationally might ask the question “Would society suffer if this maxim were a universal law?” A rational person could conclude yes, because people would be unable to trust each other, and thus would be unable to function in society. Thus this person would conclude it would be immoral to lie. However a rational person could also conclude no, because society already operates in a manner where people can and do lie, and that human reason is capable of sifting through lies and making judgments, and that it would thus simply require an adjustment to the societal formula. This person then concludes that it is moral to lie in that case because the maxim could serve as a universal law. Thus, a rational person could come to two completely different conclusions, which are both valid as neither of them is a hard, provable fact. From this it can be concluded that “A rational person thinking rationally” is not a good criterion for determining the validity of an argument. This can be considered to be proven because I, a rational person thinking rationally, have found it to be proven. What do you all think? Have I correctly represented the argument of rationality? Can you provide any alternatives?

In our classes this week, we held our first official symposia, and learned about Immanuel Kant and the categorical Imperative. Applying what we learned today to the social and political thoughts on justice of the last weeks, we encounter certain conflicts. For one, Aristotle understands justice in terms of human interaction, and when an injustice has been done, it needs to be corrected with a system of reconciliatory justice.  But using Kant’s Categorical Imperative, we cannot justify certain reconciliatory actions as moral. Kant’s understanding of moral action dictates that certain actions are immoral, but proving the immorality of an action and the injustice of a situation are different. It is immoral to steal, and therefore Robin Hoods stealing from the rich to feed the poor is Immoral, but is not inherently unjust.  So while Kant’s definition of morality is an excellent standard against which to measure individual actions, it does not accurately provide us with a tool to measure social and political thought. I also have qualms about the thoroughness of his understanding of morality.  While an action can be justified yet immoral, would it not be one’s moral obligation to commit an immoral act to preserve another form an injustice? Viewing morality as a measure against which to make decisions seems irrational when presented with the unfortunate reality of being in a situation where one must commit an immoral action. Does the logic of morality hold any bearing when forced into truly dire situation, or alternatively, inconsequential situations?  Do I not have a moral obligation to lie to the Nazis about Anne Frank’s location, and commit the morally wrong action, but spare my fellow man pain and suffering? Does my choice to run a red light when there is no cop around have significance? Although the future is undefined, and improbable, Man chooses to impose his reality onto it and make certain assumptions so as to function with the passage of time. Why should our system of morality be limited to our inability to exactly define the future? But I suppose I am giving Kant too little credit. After all, his morality is both logical and an excellent goal to strive towards. My criticism only stems from an inability to correspond the morality of my actions to the Categorical Imperative in terms of their absolute role in decision making.

Justifiable Torture


            Today in class we discussed the level of justice behind interrogational torture, and whether the torture of one in order to save a greater population was ultimately just, according to Immanuel Kant. In Kant’s categorical imperative he claims that one should act only in such a way that you always treat humanity (whether in yourself or another), never simply as a means but an end-in-itself. The understanding was that since the interrogation would only be using the perpetrator as a mean to get to the bottom of the issue at hand the torture would be unjust. I must raise the question, that does not the lack of value put into humanity by the one being tortured warrant a reason for torturous interrogation.
            By no means am claiming that anyone that has knowledge of a violent crime on a more individual basis should be pulled into some room and water-boarded until they confess. On most occasions the justice system will be able to find the end without torture, but there are ones where torture can be warranted. In events of imminent attack, or dealing with those who have no value for human life, or dealing with those create an essence for time extraordinary measures may have to be taken.
            To discuss the level of justice behind interrogation, I will try to prove it just through the categorical imperatives that Kant presents us with. The object of the torture has not treated humanity as an end. To restore the importance in humanity one would have to find the epicenter and eliminate it. By torturing one who is not willing to release information in order to restore that importance you are making him or her apart of the end, considering he is included in the importance of humanity. The torture also creates a level of rectification that we have included as apart of all of the justice systems we have discussed thus far in some way, shape, or form.
            Kant also claims in his categorical imperative that one should act only in such a way that you could will the maxim of your actions as a universal law. Protecting the humanity of anyone person, to me, justifies the torture. There could be a universal law that in times of eminent danger to humanity by a person that has no value for it, extraordinary for interrogation are justifiable. The protection of humanity therefore would be a maxim that would work in a kingdom of ends.

Exclusions in Kant's Justice


           In Immanuel Kant’s “A Definition of Justice”, he is in concurrence with Aristotle on the bases that justice is an external issue. Accordingly, he describes justice as a state where the will of one person can be coexisting with another without disrupting or restricting the freedom of the latter.  Along with this description in order for justice to be applicable to society it must follow three conditions. First, “it applies only to the external and practical relationships of one person to another in which their actions can in fact exert an influence on each other”. (150) Second, “it applies only to the relationship of a will to another person’s will, not to his wishes or desires”. (150) Third, “justice does not take into consideration the matter of the will”. (150) Therefore, in accord with these conditions, justice should be used to keep order between relationships and altercations between humans.
            However, Kant also establishes the idea of the right of necessity, “necessity has no law; but there still cannot be any necessity that will make what is unjust legal”. (156) The example he uses to illustrate this point is a scenario of two shipwrecked men who both are in equal danger of dying. Yet, in the fight for survival one man pushes the other of the plank to have himself. Under Kant’s definition of justice and necessity he states that while the man may have to battle with some moral issues, he will not face any penal issues. The assailant’s act was completely voluntary, he acknowledged of the possible outcome of the victim, and was not coerced by any external factors besides the fear of his own survival.
Furthermore, in class we discussed the basic principles of Kant’s philosophy.  We discussed deontology and categorical imperatives. Through these we know three conditions: that the maxim of every action must be applicable as a universal law; to act in such a way that you always treat humanity (whether in yourself or another), never simply as a means, but always as an end-in-itself; and to act in accordance with the maxim of a member giving universal laws for a merely possible kingdom of ends. So under the first categorical imperative, is the issue of self preservation through violence a maxim for a universal law? Or in the second in the imperative, do the ends (possible survival) succeed the means (murder)? Should the act of self preservation through violence be considered or evaluated under the laws of justice, or does the right of necessity exclude it? 

Friday, September 7, 2012

Doctrine of the Mean


According to Aristotle, justice is restoring or maintaining a proper balance. He hardly distinguishes the justice that deals with crime and those that deal with commerce. The only difference is that he calls the former involuntary and the later voluntary. For some, it might be hard to see what the two have in common, but for Aristotle, they both involve exchanges. Aristotle believes that anything that could result in an unfair advantage or disadvantage is a concern of justice. It makes the connection that inflated prices and physical assault are both, essentially, grouped into the same category.

We talked briefly in class about “zero sum” goods – things like money, honor, and safety. Particular justice encompasses these things.  A gain for one person results in a loss to another. Aristotle associates particular injustice with greed or desire. Distributive justice, on the other hand, is where the people who make the most contributions to society receive the greatest rewards. Aristotle’s version of distributive justice seems slightly biased. In his time, women and slaves did not have the freedom to do as they pleased, so they would receive a lesser share of the wealth. Those who have the greatest privilege have the greatest access to wealth.

Aristotle’s Doctrine of the Mean says that justice is a state where people are given things based on their merit and usefulness, and injustice is where people have either too much or too little. However, usefulness and merit can be judged differently at different times and by different people. A bus driver would be very useful to someone that doesn’t have a car, but they would be completely useless for someone who can drive themselves. Numerous other jobs seem worthless to one group but are necessary to the functionality of other people’s lives.

So how would we determine who deserved what? Who would be the one to decide? It would be near impossible for whom ever to decide what would be fair for everyone. I don’t think there would be a reliable way for any person or group to decide the merit of others.

So, what do some of you guys think about it? Do you think that there could be a fair, proper, and just way to adequately decide what the worth of someone would be? Is there a way to disregard any bias that someone would have when they were deciding?