Today in class we ended with the idea
of injustice in finical situations. If we have a shop that is over
charging all of the populous, and within the populous there is a
group of people who do not care whether they are being over charged
or not. Now this shop is not special. Everything that it sells, other
stores sell it as well. Now, I believe, that people, who wish to buy
the items that are sold at this store, will aim to go to the stores
competition, assuming lower prices. Now the people who don't care
about the amount of money they are spending, they will continue to go
to this store for purchases. Now is the store being unjust in this
circumstance? They are taking advantage of their customers' apathy to
high costs. The customers are getting what they want, and the store
is getting what it wants. There is a balance to this situation, as
well as a sense of equality, because the customers are placing a
lower value on money than the rest of the populace, which is why they
still shop at the “expensive” store. In this case, everyone gets
what they want (remembering the rest of the populace also has stores
that fit their preferences). I believe this situation is not unjust.
But there is another side to this.
What if everyone does not get what they want? What is there is only
one store in an accessible spot? I think that this has potential to
become an unjust situation. If the community is being overcharged,
and values for certain items are being skewed, it becomes difficult
for the community to reach a balance with the store. If the store has
essential items, the store ends up taking a situation of power among
the community, and they are unable to resist. The people are forces
to submit to the will of the store. If the store sells the only
medicine around, then people who could not afford the medicine would
either perish or be forced to go into debt (which could lead anywhere
from monthly payments to indentured servitude). This economic
situation allows for denial of rights, and sets the system of laws
and as well as orients the benefits toward the store. And there is no
way that the store will not be taking advantage of the villagers
situation and encroaching on their right to justice, because they
already are by overcharging the community.
What do you guys think? I would very much like to learn and know, if I have misunderstood, or ignored a certain aspect.