Friday, September 7, 2012

Justice in Economics


Today in class we ended with the idea of injustice in finical situations. If we have a shop that is over charging all of the populous, and within the populous there is a group of people who do not care whether they are being over charged or not. Now this shop is not special. Everything that it sells, other stores sell it as well. Now, I believe, that people, who wish to buy the items that are sold at this store, will aim to go to the stores competition, assuming lower prices. Now the people who don't care about the amount of money they are spending, they will continue to go to this store for purchases. Now is the store being unjust in this circumstance? They are taking advantage of their customers' apathy to high costs. The customers are getting what they want, and the store is getting what it wants. There is a balance to this situation, as well as a sense of equality, because the customers are placing a lower value on money than the rest of the populace, which is why they still shop at the “expensive” store. In this case, everyone gets what they want (remembering the rest of the populace also has stores that fit their preferences). I believe this situation is not unjust.

But there is another side to this. What if everyone does not get what they want? What is there is only one store in an accessible spot? I think that this has potential to become an unjust situation. If the community is being overcharged, and values for certain items are being skewed, it becomes difficult for the community to reach a balance with the store. If the store has essential items, the store ends up taking a situation of power among the community, and they are unable to resist. The people are forces to submit to the will of the store. If the store sells the only medicine around, then people who could not afford the medicine would either perish or be forced to go into debt (which could lead anywhere from monthly payments to indentured servitude). This economic situation allows for denial of rights, and sets the system of laws and as well as orients the benefits toward the store. And there is no way that the store will not be taking advantage of the villagers situation and encroaching on their right to justice, because they already are by overcharging the community.

What do you guys think? I would very much like to learn and know, if I have misunderstood, or ignored a certain aspect. 

The Ideal Leader



In both our class and popular news, political ethics and the ways of current politicians has been a heated subject. Seeing as how the presidential election is merely weeks away, it makes sense for the citizens of the United States to be taking closer looks into what type of qualities and characteristics are important in a leader.
While I was reading the assigned text “Justice,” from Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, the passage beneath the heading “political justice,” struck me as particularly interesting. From these words of Aristotle, it is easy to agree that, “if a ruler is just, he seems to profit nothing by it”(p. 84). However, it is obvious that throughout history and even into society today, leaders almost always receive benefits not accessible to ordinary citizens. It is questionable though whether or not these advantages are necessary when one single person holds so much power and represents the masses.
Is there justice in having excessive amounts of security when it is so easy to become the target of anger and resentment? As members of a society that strongly values equality, it can be argued that our head of state is not within reach. Of course, because of the way our justice system is set up our voices are to be heard through elected representatives. In my opinion, there should be a balance between having, for instance, the secret service that offer protection 24/7, and never having the opportunity to sit down and chat with the person people trust with their nation.
Another arguable injustice concerning the leaders of today is the amount of wealth they accumulate. Millions of dollars are spent every year on political campaigns in the United States. It is right or just to have kids going without food and clothing when the people they are supposes to look up to have all that plus more. It can be really difficult to build a connection with someone that seems so different. On the other hand, isn’t it the American Dream to aspire to do more with ones life? Everyone wants his or her leader to represent them in a positive light and unfortunately poor economic situations, while they are understandable in some cases, limit the amount of respect others have for you. This in its self is an injustice.
Unfortunately the world is not ideal. It would be nice to have a completely good and justice world with perfect leaders as described by Plato and Aristotle but realistically it is not plausible. Personally, Aristotle summed up the faultless candidate for the next president of the United States in a short statement—“a ruler is a guardian of what is just and hence of what is equal [and so must not award himself too many goods]”(p. 84).

Involuntary Voting


With the election swiftly approaching, each of the front-running candidates will likely be discussing and debating their stances on tax rates. Each candidate’s plan clearly differs on a number of issues, including individual income taxes, investment income tax rates, and tax breaks (Here’s a link to a fairly recent, straight-forward layout of each candidate’s policies: http://money.cnn.com/2012/09/07/news/economy/tax-obama-romney/ ).  In my mind, this issue seems to be at a crossroads  with Artistotle’s Distributive Justice.  The fact that citizens in different salary brackets pay different salary tax percentages suggests that we’ve agreed that an equitable system of taxation is better than an equal one.  I’ll start with the assumption that neither plan attains a perfectly equitable system of taxation. Though both strategies may be imperfect, the fact that their tax plans differ at all suggests that one plan should be more just than the other (unless you think perfect equitability would come from an exact mean of the two plans).  It might help if you think of justice in this case as being a point on a number line, where either extreme represents a violation of distributive justice in some way.  If you place a point on the number line for each candidate and allow that point to represent the sum effect of all of their tax stances, one of the candidates must necessarily be closer to perfect equity (again, unless the two points are equidistant on opposite sides of the most just position).

When viewing this in the light of Distributive Justice, the situation is almost disturbing. One candidate must necessarily have an objectively more just plan for taxation, and since the other candidate’s constituents wouldn’t voluntarily do an injustice to themselves, why are they voting for that person?  Assuming that a whole legion of voters aren’t maliciously attempting to benefit from an unfair tax system, why wouldn’t we hold the other candidate’s voters responsible for an injustice? What is the issue that allows them to escape from such responsibility? It’s clearly the agent’s decision who to vote for. Are they not armed with enough knowledge to realize that their candidate’s tax plan is less just? Perhaps they are being coerced into accepting a less just tax strategy through the candidates’ stances on other issues (I‘m thinking something along the lines of a religious person not being able to accept the ideas of abortion and homosexual marriage or a low-income family not being able to accept the repeal of the Healthcare Reform Act.)? Regardless of the specific cause, it would seem that a population of voters are involuntarily voting for a less just system of taxes. Should such a situation be allowed to arise in politics?

I think in some cases, a voter realizes that one tax system would have a greater benefit to them, regardless of how equitable it is. These people may actually be committing an injustice.  I don't believe this is the case with the majority of people, however.  I think many people are simply coerced into a particular vote due to other issues at stake, or they don't have an intimate knowledge of what an equitable system would look like.

What do you think? It's not hard to imagine this general idea being applied to other political issues, which could mean that "involuntary voting" is a systematic occurrence in our political system.

Aristotle's Justice and Moral Obligations


During class today, we offered up some thought experiments for determining whether, by Aristotle’s standards, an action would be considered an injustice.  Injustices, we read, must be voluntary, and to be voluntary, they must be

1.  Up to the agent
2.  Done with knowledge, and
3.  Not coincidental or coerced

Some examples that we discussed were driving carefully but accidentally hitting a pedestrian with your car, driving recklessly and accidentally hitting a pedestrian with your car, and being coerced into hitting a pedestrian with your car.

Professor Johnson also clarified that, by Aristotle’s model, the law does not always produce justice.  The example of Jean Valjean’s imprisonment for stealing bread to feed his sister’s starving child is a good one.  In that scenario, the law governed the punishment he received (5 years for stealing the bread), but it seems a great injustice.  It seems that there is an imbalance between the amount of bread Jean Valjean got out of the exchange and the amount of punishment he received for it.

This example of justice not coinciding with the law made me think about the idea of moral obligations.
I’m sure we’ve all entertained some hypothetical ethical dilemmas from time to time.  I know I’ve talked about these with friends many times (maybe I’m strange).  One example may be this:

You are walking along a path, and you come upon a lake, where a stranger is drowning. 

Aristotle would likely suggest that the drowning person, let’s call him Bob, is involuntarily suffering an injustice (the only way one can).  He is a terrible swimmer, who attempted to swim alone, and by some accident, he is now drowning.

There are lots of ways to complicate this scenario, but let's just assume that you are an excellent swimmer and know that you could save the man’s life.  In fact, the lake seems pretty small and, oh look, you’re wearing a swimsuit already.  In other words, it would trouble you very little to save Bob's life.  Many would suggest in this situation, that you are morally obligated to save the drowning man.  Legally, you’re not.  The Good Samaritan law in Tennessee only suggests that if you intervene to help and some damage comes to Bob, you shouldn’t be held legally responsible.  You could, by all means, walk away and let Bob drown. 

How would Aristotle view the situation?  Is it your responsibility to rectify Bob’s injustice?  If you let him drown, are you performing an injustice?  You were not the distributor, determining Bob’s circumstances, so it seems like you would have no responsibility to save him, but walking away clearly seems like the wrong thing to do.  Is voluntarily allowing an avoidable injustice to happen (the death of Bob by drowning) the same thing as committing an injustice? 

What if he shouts for help?

I’d really like to know what you guys think.  I think perhaps you would not be unjust to leave Bob to die, you may just be a huge jerk.  It might, for the passerby, not be a question of justice at all.  Bob is suffering a deficiency, but is it your responsibility to rectify it?



Source:
Aristotle. Justice, from the Nicomachean Ethics. Justice. Ed. Jonathan Westphal. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Pub., 1996. 73-94. Print.

--- Katie Sanders

Can We Consider the Repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Just?


Last night Illinois Senator Dick Durbin spoke to the Democratic National Convention just before President Obama came on stage to deliver his nomination acceptance speech. While there were many interesting elements to the DNC speakers last night, as well as this entire week, something particular struck my during Senator Durbin’s brief address-- the senator attributed Obama's success with restoring women's rights and ending don't ask don't tell  with the characteristic of "justice.” 
My question followed, then, does Senator Durbin’s use of the term comply with Aristotle's definition of justice? 
First I think we must take time to decide whether we consider these social inequalities are in fact injustices. Injustice according to Aristotle is the presence of excess or deficiency in a relationship between people where the distributor of the injustice is acting voluntarily-- with intent, knowledge, and without coincidence. Is this the case? First, we must determine if there is a relationship in this instance. Perhaps if we consider the relationship here to be the connection between representatives and decision makers in the government and these groups of people (namely women and the GLBT community), we can accept this to be an instance of relationship.While these relationships are not necessarily personal today (and the relationship between people who initially wrote the laws and the current population is certainly not personal) this is an instance of the government as the distributor of injustice.  
We also must consider whether the restoration of "equality" in this situation constitutes justice. A we discussed in class, there is a difference between equal and equitable. In order to consider the legal discrepancy of rights of, say, GLBT members of the military, you must first believe that a just distribution of human social rights that is equitable is in fact one that is equal. Granted, then we must consider if other groups also require equal and equitable rights, for example convicted felons. In order to view the repeal of the Dont Ask, Dont Tell policy as an act of restoring justice, we must decide upon a definition of social justice that is applicable to all groups within society. Here, of course, we have stumbled upon the basis for the “Religious Right’s” argument against gay rights; in their opinion, there is not injustice in this situation because an equitable distribution of rights would not allow for gay rights, because gays (according to this conservative mode of thinking) do not deserve equal rights. 
However, if we consider that social rights ought to be distributed equally, because in this case what is equitable is also equal, then (and only then) can we consider Obama's successful repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell an act of undoing a situation of deficient rights, in other words an act of justice.  

Is Separate but Equal Justifiable?



Throughout our recent classes, we have discussed heavily the subject of whether justice is defined by equality. While equality does play a vital role in defining justice, does separate but equal fall into the same category of defining justice? As we have seen over the course of America's history, separate but equal does not constitute justice under our law because what was separate was not always equal. However, justice could potentially be defined by separate but equal in other countries in which their religious beliefs result in a far more strict society.
Currently in Saudi Arabia, the female population is revolting against their unjust society. The opportunities that are offered to women are slim to none which, as a result, have caused the women to desire a far more equal and modern society. In order for women to receive the rights they desire, the female population of Saudi Arabia has created a city of their own in which they can create their own opportunities and have the freedom to do as they please. The severity of the segregation that is up and coming in this country has caused many United States politicians and citizens to recall the Jim Crow Laws that were establish as a result of the segregation of blacks and whites. The question arises of whether or not the creation of this single sex city is actually a viable solution to the lack of equality in Saudi Arabia considering the city was thought of by women, for women. Personally, I believe that while it may be a step in the right direction for women to obtain the rights they deserve, it is not completely just. Although women will have the opportunity to have freedoms, when they leave the bubble that is their city, they will once again lose all rights that they had obtained living separately. So does the idea of justice change under the rules of a stricter society therefore justifying separate but equal, or do the ideas we have created as Americans still play a role in this situation?


Works Cited
Khaleeli, Homa. "Saudi Arabia's Women-only Cities Are No Blueprint for Liberation." The Guardian. Guardian News and Media, 13 Aug. 2012. Web. 06 Sept. 2012. <http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/aug/13/saudi-arabia-women-only-city>.

View, World With A. "Women Only: Saudi Arabia Further Segregates Society." Forbes. Forbes Magazine, 15 Aug. 2012. Web. 06 Sept. 2012. <http://www.forbes.com/sites/worldviews/2012/08/15/women-only-saudi-arabia-further-segregates-society/>.

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Is the mean just mediocre?

     When thinking about Aristotle's idea of virtues and justice, the first thing that popped into my head was Rhodes College students.  Aristotle describes justice as the "complete virtue to the highest degree" (75), and goes on to say that this virtue of justice is an intermediate between two much and too little (78), between profit and loss (80), between the extremes; "Justice is a mean" (85).
     Now that we have that, back to my thoughts on Rhodes' students.  When I look at Rhodes I see three categories of students: those who get glory and recognition for doing phenomenal things, being incredibly genius, saving the world, etc.; those who get a different type of recognition for setting things on fire, selling drugs, or getting in serious and noticeable trouble with the administration; and finally those who fall in between those two extremes. In today's society, it seems that those of us who fall in between (the mean) are easily forgotten and can be seen as boring or simply mediocre (NOTICE: not necessarily reality, just how the majority of society appears to see it, or how we ourselves, as products of this society, have been raised to see it). Today, only the extremes are glorified and noticed in society while the in-betweeners are not note worthy. If using Aristotle's ideal of justice as this intermediate virtue that serves as an equilibrium, these "mean" people, though achieving this equilibrium in general terms, fall through the cracks unnoticed by their peers and superiors. Although Aristotle makes a good argument for how we should strive for justice in order to maintain happiness (75), can society today understand that happiness does not always come with being recognized and glorified?  In today's society when the extremes seem to be a point of desire for many people and the mean merely a mediocre fence to be sat on, how do you motivate one to try and be virtuous in terms of Aristotle? Or is it necessary for this mean group to not be glorified in one extreme or the other, but rather does this non appreciated group understand more about virtues and justice by remaining "mediocre" in standards today? 

Work Cited
Aristotle. "Aristotle, 'Justice,' from the Nicomachean Ethics." Justice. Ed. Jonathan Westphal. Indianapolis,        IN: Hackett Pub., 1996. 73-94. 

Inequalities of Justice

Aristotle talks about justice in rectification. In this case Aristotle states that an injustice can be rectified by taking something from the offender and giving it to the victim. But, can this be considered to be true? Can specific values always be determined for specific objects or injustices? Is it possible to fix any injustice and create a situation to where neither side is faced with a "loss?"

In cases where money is stolen it can always be paid back. $100 will always be the same as $100 no matter who has it. But, what if a family has a "treasure" and it means more to them than the monetary value. If a family has a sword and it's a family heirloom that has been passed down in the family for generations it will mean more to them than is actual worth. If the sword is worth $2000 and its stolen and sold on the black market the family has lost their heirloom. If the criminal is caught he can be made to repay the $2000 but the sword cannot be recovered. How can this be considered equal? the victims have lost a priceless item and they only received $2000. There is no conceivable way to say the family is just as well off without the sword even if they are paid the $2000 the sword is worth. How can justice be rectified when an item has sentimental value worth far more than the monetary value of the sword.

Also, if someone is murdered how can any one ever rectify the injustice that has been done. If a child is killed no amount of money can make the family feel better, they will never have their child back. That injustice can never be truly rectified, how can anyone place a value to the life of a human? How can anyone determine what an object means to a family? How can a value be placed on sentiment and intrinsic value? In many cases an injustice can be rectified through money and other various actions, but there are a lot of cases where justice cannot be truly rectified.

Knowing and Doing or Doing and Knowing?

Reading Plato and then Aristotle is interesting because although Aristotle was Plato’s student, there are many distinct differences between their views. At the end of Wednesday’s class, Dr. J stated that for Plato, to know the good is to do the good while for Aristotle, to do the good is to know the good. It can be concluded that Plato’s view of virtue is focused on wisdom. If one is wise, virtue will follow and this virtue is sufficient for happiness. For Aristotle, although wisdom is the highest virtue, it isn’t the key to having all virtues. Knowing the good is not enough in Aristotle’s view because one’s habits must reflect virtue for a person to be virtuous. Therefore, from Aristotle’s perspective, virtue is not sufficient for the good life yet it is necessary. Having read a little bit of both Plato and Aristotle, which seems more plausible? It seems that Aristotle’s view emphasizes the actions of doing good in order to truly understand what is good while Plato focuses on knowing what is good and then acting accordingly. In today’s society, which view is more prevalent? Is one more realistic then the other? Is it possible for a community to function efficiently if some people adopt Plato’s method while others focus on Aristotle’s ways?

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

Rhodes Alum at the DNC

I have posted a link to a short speech that Claudia Kennedy, a Rhodes alum made at the Democratic National Convention last night. It is only about two minutes long but it's kind of cool to see a graduate of our school up there.