For the past two thousand years philosophers have strived to define the word “justice.” Some tried hard
to prove Plato’s definition of justice that says that a just man is a man who
is where he is supposed to be. Still, after all this time, Plato’s definition
is not considered complete. No one has really come up with a concrete
definition of justice. Many of the definitions that we discussed in class contained
subjective words like “fairness.” To use the word “fair” one needs a definition
of “fair.” But who determines fairness? In any situation there might be many
fair actions that one can take but which action is the fairest action? So using
the word fair, doesn’t really help us define the world “justice.”
I believe that in order
to find a more concrete definition of justice, we have to look at its
counterpart: injustice. If we can better understand injustice, then the
definition of justice will be clearer. So,
what really is injustice? Is it sex trafficking of young girls? Is it tyranny?
Is it racism? Is it child labor? In my mind, these are all not only unfair but
also injustices; this is because I believe that in all of these instances the
strong are taking advantage of the weak. So, I would define injustice as the
strong taking advantage of the weak. Therefore I could say that Justice can be
defined as equal opportunities for all. In a just society the strong will not
infringe upon the rights of the weak.
In class we discussed
the Voter ID laws and if they are just. If we do define injustice as the strong
taking advantage of the weak then I would say the Voter ID laws are quite
unjust. Voter ID laws can be considered poll taxes (which we banned decades
ago). Some people are not able to get state IDs because they either don’t have
the financial means or they don’t have an address. The people who can’t get IDs
are the poor and if we expand that further we can say that the poor probably
consist of mostly African Americans, college students, and other minorities
like immigrants. Which make up the bulk of the Democratic Party. So, these
Voter ID laws are made to suppress a group of people; even the congressman who
came up with the law, said that this law will make Mitt Romney win the
election. So why is this unjust? When the strong (politicians and rich people
who have influence over the politicians) take away such a right from the poor
then I would consider the strong to be unjust. If this kind of law passes then
the strong will get people that they support into the government. This would be
quite a slippery slope because as more and more politicians who support the
strong get power, the weak will cease to have a voice. I believe that in order
to live in a just America, we need to get rid of these Voter ID laws or offer
free ways to get State issued IDs. This way everyone can have a voice.